Using Testing to Find Nut Factor, K
“What is my Nut Factor, K?” I get this question often and the honest answer is that sometimes I don’t know.
There is not a K table for every bolted flange assembly combination and all the math in the world is not a replacement for real-world testing. I use the BoltSafe Load Measuring Systems to help me find the Nut Factor, K for critical joints. By slowly dialing my torque wrench to specific values and keeping the Selected Assembly Bolt Stress, Sbsel constant, I can find the Nut Factor, K for just about any bolt/nut/washer/lubricant combination.
The Nut Factor, K has a huge impact on the Assembly Bolt Torque, Tb so any uncertainty can negatively affect your bolted joint assembly. As a matter of fact, junk K values will result in junk Assembly Bolt Torque, Tb values. Testing for the actual K factor for your custom bolted joint assemblies is the best way to ensure leak-free joints.
Appendix 2 Bolt Area
Be careful with plugging Bolt Area (Ab) from Appendix 2 into your PCC-1 Appendix O calculation!
While performing a third party review I noticed something fishy about a calculated Selected Assembly Bolt Stress (Sbsel) value. It turned out that the Bolt Area (Ab) was off by the number of bolts. A simple mistake that almost turned into a terrible facility torque table!
You can’t directly plug in the Bolt Area (Ab) from the ASME Appendix 2 Flange calculation into the Bolt Area (Ab) needed for the ASME PCC-1 Appendix O calculations. This is because the Bolt Area (Ab) from Appendix 2 Flange calculation includes the number of bolts in it already while the ASME PCC-1 Appendix O does not. Notice that the ASME PCC-1 Appendix O calculation multiplies by the Number of Bolts (nb) in the denominator.
Third party reviews save money. Metalmark Engineering would love to perform your third party review.
Use Load Cells to Ensure Bolt Load
Are your bolts losing their bolt load over time? Installing load cells to your bolts during your next turnaround will help give you the answer.
It can be difficult to predict if a bolted flange assembly is going to start leaking over time due to loss in bolt load. Unfortunately some gasket types, like PTFE, can lose over 50% of their original gasket stress a week after assembly. This means the operating bolt load may not be high enough to retain the Minimum Gasket Operating Stress, Sgmin-O required by ASME PCC-1 Appendix O.
I like to use BoltSafe load cells because of the intuitive hand held display and the ability to easily export to Excel.